Personal tools

Pine River Superfund Site

From Great Lakes Wiki

The Velsicol Chemical plant
The Velsicol Chemical plant

The Pine River Superfund Site is located on the Pine River in St Louis, Michigan, in the "middle of the mitten" 50 miles north of Lansing. Its environmental problems stem from the Michigan Chemical (now Velsicol) plant that was once on the banks of the Pine River. The plant produced both DDT and PBB, and dumped waste and pollution in the Pine River until it was shut down in 1978. The St Louis community is heavily involved in the clean-up process, headed by the Pine River Citizen's Advisory Group alongside the EPA and DEQ.

[edit] History

Contamination of the Pine River began in the mid-nineteenth century when logging and farming first tainted the banks of the Pine River. In the 1930s, petroleum refineries went up along the river and Michigan Chemical (later purchased by Velsicol) in St. Louis and the Leonard refinery, in Alma, set up shop. The Superfund Site stems from the Michigan Chemical/Velsicol facility that produced both DDT and PBB there.

For a full, detailed description of the sequence of events, see the Full Timeline

This timeline follows the Pine River/St Louis, Michigan area from the beginnings of human interaction to the present. It contains a detailed list of companies involved with Pine River pollution, the levels of pollution, and the legal battles of the Pine River CAG.

Much of its data comes from the Full Pine River CAG timeline.

The tables below provide historical context for St Louis while Velsicol was in operation there and also after they left.


[edit] Velsicol in St Louis

The Superfund sites of the Pine River Watershed resulted from the massive dumping of byproducts from DDT production and a separate ecological disaster involving fire retardant made with polybrominanted biphenyls (PBBs) by the Velsicol Chemical Company. Here is the story of Velsicol, from their early days as Michigan Chemical Co., to their departure as a result of the PBB catastrophe.


[edit] Velsicol's departure

In 1978, Velsicol agreed to shut down its St. Louis factory. Two years later, under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), or Superfund Act, the state and the owners of Michigan Chemical contained the site and created a landfill for much of the contaminated materials. This is the story of St. Louis since Velsicol vacated, and the dangers they dealt with.

[edit] Problems with the Pine River Superfund

A number of problems remain for the community of St Louis, Michigan. A waste dump or Burn Pit across the river has yet to be cleaned up because of its unusual jurisdiction. The water supply still has measurable traces of pCBSA, a byproduct of DDT that residents are exposed to. An on-going legal battle with AIG Insurance over funds has also been a focus of the group for years. With all of these problems, the small community has its hands full

Tombstone put in place at the entrance of the Velsicol Superfund Site to serve as a warning.
Tombstone put in place at the entrance of the Velsicol Superfund Site to serve as a warning.

[edit] The Burn Pit

The Burn Pit is a former dump site of Michigan Chemical/Velsicol that was used to disgard chemical byproducts and contaminants, often in sealed barrels. When Velsicol was forced to shut down and clean its site in 1980, some of the material in the Burn Pit was dug up, but it was paid little attention. This has left a portion of highly contaminated land on the North bank of the Pine River. Unfortunately, the EPA and DEQ Superfund Site at Pine River doesn't cover the Burn Pit. While officials have taken measurements at the site, there are no tentative plans to clean it more thoroughly, although the Citizen's Advisory Group continues to push for a full cleanup.

[edit] St Louis' water supply

Recent testing still shows amounts of pCBSA (parachlorobenzene sulfonic acid), a byproduct of DDT, in the river and drinking water.

"This is the city's biggest problem," said Mayor George Kubin. Though detected levels are below EPA standards, the cause for concern among officials is the uncertainty associated with the lesser-known chemical, he said.

Dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL) is a syrup-like compound that is moving off the Velsicol site, recontaminating the river and, perhaps, the water table under the site. The EPA and DEQ are conducting an ongoing study of the levels of these chemicals in the Pine River and in wells across the city. pCBSA has been detected routinely in 5 of the 6 wells, although the range is very low. However, the measurements have risen in small increments.

[edit] The future of Pine River

Local residents and officials adamantly seek to restore St Louis' image as more than a "Toxic Town". Community events on the river, job creation and higher property values are tactics used to shed the pollution stigma. Though attracting people is important, St Louis still wants to maintain its small-town feel, according to Mayor George Kubin.

[edit] Citizen’s Advisory Group (CAG)

Ed Lorenz, former chair of the Pine River CAG, talks about the CAG's

formation in 1997. When the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

began retesting by the Velsicol site in the 1990s, they found dangerous

levels of DDT and PBB remaining in the Pine River. When brought to the

community's attention, they quickly organized the official Pine River CAG.

The Pine River Citizen's Advisory Group began operation at the end of 1997 to provide community feedback to the United States Environmental Protection Agency for the second cleanup at the Velsicol Chemical Site in St. Louis, Michigan. Made up of concerned citizens of St Louis alongside teachers from Alma College, the group made full cleanup and remediation their top priority, as well as seeking reparations from the offending companies.

While continuing to monitor the cleanup of DDT in the Pine River by the old plant site, the CAG became involved in the EPA litigation against Total Petroleum for air and water violations at its Alma Refinery.

They also helped out in the cleanup of Horse Creek, a runoff of Pine River that became a siphon for contaminants. The creek was dredged by hand by CAG member Murray Burrello, a geologist from Alma College, and his student group. Pictures of the cleanup

The Task Force has also pursued concerns with contamination at the other two superfund sites and a radioactive waste dump near St. Louis and at related sites impacted by the petro-chemical industry. In addition to monitoring EPA and other federal and state clean-up efforts in the watershed, the Task Force has aggressively pursued making the responsible parties, not the general treasury, pay for clean-ups. Their ongoing legal battle with AIG Insurance has potentially been settled for $91,000, but this is only 1/10th of the full $100 million policy that Velsicol and Fruit of the Loom had out on their site. The Pine River CAG is also holding a DDT Conference in March that will feature DDT experts from around the world.

The group is highly active, and meets monthly. They actively review EPA information on the site, and seek to keep both the EPA and Velsicol accountable for the Superfund site in St. Louis.

[edit] News

[edit] Pine River Superfund Citizen News

  • Eugene Kenaga International DDT ConferenceOn March 14, 2008, Alma College (Alma, MI) is hosting the conference on DDT and its effect on human health and the environment. It will bring together experts from around the country and abroad to frame and lead discussions. Projects at the conference will regard other persistent organic pollutants (POPs). The conference is jointly sponsored by Alma College, the Pine River Citizen's Advisory Group(CAG) and the Ohio Valley chapter of the Society for Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry(SETC).

Go to the Official Alma DDT Conference Page to find out more or sign up. A sign-up page will be up there soon.


Pine River Superfund Task Force.

[edit] Mainstream Media News on the Pine River Superfund

Find a new story about Pine River? Add links to the top of the list.

[edit] Related Pages

Alma College
DDT
St Louis, Michigan
Superfund
Velsicol
Velsicol in St Louis
Velsicol's departure
The future of Pine River
Eugene Kenaga International DDT Conference

[edit] Related Links

PineRiverCAG.org

Pine River environmental web site maintained by Alma College

Information on the Velsicol Superfund Site in St Louis

Information on the Gratiot County Landfill Superfund Site in St Louis

Information on the Gratiot County Gold Course Superfund Site in St Louis